Let’s Know, Which option can be best from Index Fund and Mutual Funds for Investing your money?

Are you looking to invest your money and looking to invest money in the Index Fund or Mutual Funds? This article can help you to do better investments and create wealth. Let’s do Index Fund vs Mutual Fund.

In this article, We will see that an Index fund is a better option for investment than Mutual Fund or not. we are going to clear all your doubts related to Index Fund vs Mutual Funds. So stick till the end to get the answer to all your queries in this matter.

The Index Fund and Mutual Fund are the same but a little bit different from each other. The Mutual Fund is managed by the Fund Manager and on the other hand’s Index Fund is managed by the monitors of the Index Funds. Let’s do, Index fund vs mutual fund.

You may like:-

Let’s know, How to invest in the Nifty 50 stock

What is an Index Fund and How does it work?

The Index fund contain the stocks.

An Index Fund is a kind of Mutual Fund. It is the same as the Mutual Fund and Exchange Traded Fund ( ETF ) with a portfolio constructed to Follow or track the elements of the Financial market.

An Index Fund is a group of Stocks or Bonds with the best performance. It represents the overall performance of the Financial market. 

An Index Fund is like a Passively Managed mutual fund, therefore the Fees charged (also referred to as Expense Ratio) by Index Funds are low compared to the normal Mutual Funds. And most of the time a mutual fund will rise or fall the maximum amount because the Index it’s imitating.

Investing through an Index Fund may be an excellent and safe way of diversifying your portfolio as most of the benchmark indices contain big and established companies. And it’s also loved by retail or Small investors who don’t want to burn their hand while investing within the stock exchange.

The Index Fund contains the best company in their country and the retail Investors also want to invest their money in the best company in their country. The aim of both sides is the same. So, the retail investor likes to invest in Index Funds

Pros and Cons of Index Fund


  • Unlimited Diversification
  • Low Expenses Ratio
  • Better for Long term return
  • Good Returns on Investment
  • Limited Loss


  • Vulnerable to market swings, crashes
  • Lack of flexibility
  • No human element
  • Limited gains

Let’s Know, How does it work?

When a Mutual Funds tracks a benchmark just like the Nifty, its portfolio will have the 50 stocks that comprise Nifty, within the same proportions. An index may be a group of securities defining a market segment. 

These securities are often bond market instruments or equity-oriented instruments like stocks. a number of the foremost popular indices in India are BSE Sensex and NSE Nifty. Since index funds track a specific index, they fall into passive fund management. 

The fund manager decides which stocks need to be bought and sold consistent with the composition of the underlying benchmark. Unlike actively-managed funds, there isn’t a standalone team of research analysts to spot opportunities and choose stocks.

However, there are often a few differences between fund performance and therefore the index. this is often mentioned because of the tracking error. The fund manager must work towards bringing down the tracking error the maximum amount as possible.

In the case of a weighted index, fund managers frequently stabilize the share of the securities to make sure to make a presence within the benchmark.

While an actively-managed fund strives to beat its benchmark, an index fund’s role is to match its performance thereto of its index. Index funds typically deliver returns more or less adequate to the benchmark. 

What is Mutual Fund?

Mutual Fund is a Kind of portfolio which contains the stocks which are selected by Fund Manager.

A mutual fund is collective finance from the investors for the same purpose. When you purchase a share within the mutual fund, you’ve got a little stake altogether investments included therein fund. Hence, by owning it, the investor participates in gains or losses of all the businesses within the fund. 

Mutual Fund is an Investment Fund where it pools money from many investors to invest in securities. Most of the time Mutual Funds are Actively Managed Funds which means an individual Fund Manager or a group of them proactively makes decisions for the betterment of the investors.

"A good Actively Managed Multi-Cap Mutual Fund is a very good option for having a very well-diversified portfolio as these kinds of Mutual Funds invest in stocks from different market capitalization, and are vetted by experts." - Important Think about Mutual Funds

Investing in Actively Managed Mutual Funds is a lot less risky than investing in individual securities as Mutual Funds give two of the most important safety nets – “DIVERSIFICATION” and “RISK SPREAD”.

Most of the retail investors who do not want to learn the tedious craft of making their own portfolio goes for these kinds of Mutual Funds.

But, as these kinds of funds are actively managed by a Fund Manager and a team behind him, they are generally expensive in terms of Fees or Expense Ratio.

Pros and Cons of Mutual Fund


  • portfolio management
  • risk reduction
  • dividend reinvestment
  • convenience
  • fair pricing


  • High expenses ratio
  • Sales Chargers
  • management abuses
  • tax inefficiency
  • poor trade execution

How does a Mutual fund work?

A Mutual fund is a professionally-managed investment scheme, usually this type of scheme run by an asset management company. However, It brings together a group of investors and They give money to invest.

A Mutual Fund will hire a Fund Manager to invest the money that investors have contributed. The Fund managers use that fund smartly to get better returns.

The Fund manager invests the time and knowledge to grow the fund he has got from the investors and then they get their salary or commission.

Index Fund vs Mutual Fund

Let's Know, Index fund can bet Mutual Fund? Index Fund vs Mutual Fund

So, let’s know what are the main and important differences between the Index Fund and the Mutual Fund.

Comparison, Index Fund vs Mutual Fund

 NameIndex fundMutual fund
Investment objectiveMatch the investment returns of a benchmark stock market index (e.g. the S&P 500)Beat the investment returns of a related benchmark index
Invests inStocks, bonds, and other securitiesStocks, bonds, and other securities
Management styleThe passive Investment mix is automated to match the exact holdings of the benchmark indexActive. Stock pickers (fund managers/analysts) choose fund holdings
Average management fee (expense ratio)*0.11%0.79.5%
After-fee return of $1,000 annual investment earning 7% average annual return over 30 years$99,000$86,000
Who invest in itThe Investors, Who know the basics about the Stocks, Bonds, and other securitiesSmall investor and Who doesn’t about the Stocks, Bonds, and other securities.
This table can help to understand better.

For this reason, many investors cite the low fees as a major pull of index funds over mutual funds. In this competition of ”Index Fund vs Mutual Fund”.

Which option will be best from Index Fund vs Mutual Fund?

Below you will get the perfect reasons and what require in the option you select.

Mutual fund

  • Better flexibility in moving assets around, as long as index funds generally have low flexibility thanks to their passive nature.
  • Choose an open-end fund if you would like your fund manager to possess the power to hedge positions or move assets around with general ease.
  • Generally higher potential returns, given how mutual funds are more actively managed than index funds and are getting to beat benchmark indexes.
  • Shorter-term trading thanks to how fund managers are ready to trade more actively and maximize short-term gains than those tracking indexes.

Index fund

  • Lower fees and/or lower taxes on capital gains thanks to less turnover in stocks.
  • Access to big, global stocks without having to actively invest in individual companies.
  • A “set it and forget it” format – allowing you to take a position within the fund and not need to track individual stocks or indexes a day.
  • This option will require basic knowledge about Stocks, Bonds, and other securities. In the basics, The technical analysis also takes place.

Still, both mutual funds and index funds provide convenient and sometimes high-revenue generating opportunities for investors, so make certain to try to do your homework and find out what most closely fits your investment goals and experience.

Last word from mini invest

I hope you have understood which option will best for you from “Index Fund vs Mutual Fund”. I have shared my thoughts in this article about the “Index Fund vs Mutual Fund“. If you have any recommendation or feedback you can write down in the comment box below.

Give your Feedback, Comment and recommendation